Facebook Should Bail On The Marketplace. Classifieds Will Always Be A Web 1.0 Business

by Jason Wilk on November 22, 2008

  • Supposedly, Facebook distributed a request-for-proposal to a slew of classified sites earlier this year to redo and rebrand the Facebook Marketplace (see Craigslist)
  • Speculation is that Oodle, the classifieds provider that powers Wal-Mart already has the job.
  • The marketplace needs serious help. In Silicon Valley, New York City and San Francisco combined, the amount of new listings to the Facebook Marketplace was less than 30 yesterday!
  • Classified listings is a business that never needed to make it out of the web 1.0 era. Craigslist is simple, efficient, and everything you need to find/buy things or services. Adding social features around it just doesn’t make sense. Most people agree that they’d rather not know the person they are buying something from as then it brings some sort of history with it and never feels like ‘your own’.
  • Chegg was first on the scene in 2005 to launch a mildly successful social classifieds site (for college students) up until Facebook decided to take them on. Now Chegg is a successful textbook rental company making serious dollars. Maybe Facebook should have copied that model instead of trying to kick the dead horse back to life (i’m kidding, but seriously social classifieds wil never kill Craigslist)

[Post to Twitter] 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post: Blackberry Storm Backordered Until December 5th

Next post: Faced With Server and Bandwidth Costs, Torrent Search Engines Turn to Google